quoraBest Home Warranty Companies - Comparison411.com
Comparison411 logo

Best Home Warranty Companies

A home warranty is a type of insurance that covers the expenses related to unexpected repairs of your house's appliances and systems due to factory defects, malfunctions, or breakdowns. Homeowners should feel secure knowing their homes are protected for a set amount of time against various damages, but which is the best Home Warranty Company? The key to selecting a home warranty company is to choose one with a proven track record of excellent service. If you're looking for a top-rated home warranty provider, check out our list of the 10 best home warranty companies.

Last Updated March 2023

Select Home Warranty banner

Select Home Warranty

  • Best for - low deductibles and premiums
  • Average annual premium - $404.99 - $756
  • Service requests - 24/7 phone and automated online claim service

Founded in 2012, Select Home Warranty (SHW) is a leading home warranty provider that offers protection against unexpected costs related to your home.

Select Home Warranty provides comprehensive protection for your home's appliances and fixtures. The company offers expert maintenance, parts, and service on all major home appliances such as refrigerators, dishwashers, stoves, and more.

Select Home Warranty has low plan prices, excellent customer service, and great BBB ratings. It provides coverage for plumbing, electrical wiring, heating systems, appliances, and more. Select Home Warranty also has very low deductibles.



Select Home Warranty logo
Choice Home Warranty banner

Choice Home Warranty

  • Best for - Basic coverage for houses with no significant defects
  • Average annual premium - $476 - $660
  • Service requests - 24/7 Claims Hotline for medical, plumbing, or heating

Choice Home Warranty has been providing homeowners with valuable home warranty services for over a decade. They provide comprehensive coverage for homeowners of all ages, income levels, and home types and are known for exceptional customer service.

Their home warranty services cover many issues, including home repairs, replacement of damaged household items, and home upgrades. With a team of plumbers, electricians, HVAC specialists, and licensed locksmiths, they act quickly to resolve the issue and ensure that your home is functioning at an optimal level.

Choice Home Warranty offers you peace of mind 24 hours a day with repair coverage from appliance repair to leaky pipes, from AC repair to HVAC replacement, and everything in between. It provides basic home warranties that include a wide range of covered repairs and replacement options through unlimited service calls.



Choice Home Warranty logo
Liberty Home Guard banner

Liberty Home Guard

  • Best for - Low deductibles and discounts
  • Average annual premium - $499.99 - $639.99
  • Service requests - online presence with 24/7 phone support

Liberty provides peace of mind in your home with the best protection and service to fix and repair your house at an affordable price and with great discounts.

Liberty provides coverage for structural issues such as water damage or unexpected significant repairs to appliances such as the boiler/furnace, air conditioner, A/C, refrigerators, and more.

Liberty Home Guard's warranty is designed to fit the needs of both homeowners and contractors. The warranty covers the cost of repairing or replacing any defective equipment or replacement parts for the structure's lifetime.

It also features a 30-day repair guarantee. In addition, Liberty Home Guard gives you 24/7 access to qualified professionals trained to handle all repairs or replacement issues on your property.



Liberty Home Guard logo
American Home Shield banner

American Home Shield

  • Best for - Covering all major home appliances
  • Average annual premium - $500 - $700
  • Service requests - Available on phone and online 24/7

Having dysfunctional appliances at home can be very inconvenient. American Home Shield ensures that you get the best services in the most convenient ways and with the best pricing. American Home Shield works with highly qualified and experienced professionals who ensure that your home is well taken care of. Due to their availability online, on the phone, and on social media platforms, it is easy to reach out to them without having them interrupt your schedule.

You get coverage for; old items regardless of their age, undetected preexisting conditions, duplicates for your items, removal services for old and defective items, malfunctions caused by rust, sediments, or corrosion, maintenance-related breakdowns, and improper installations, modifications, and repairs.

With American Home Shield, you get add-ons on electronic coverage, well pumps, guest units, pools, inground spas, and septic systems. All add-ons are given at very favorable prices. They also have simple online procedures through which you file your service requests.

The organization offer discounts with the least amount being $75 and have a 24/7 support system. They offer monthly services and have room for annual packages that always have a discount according to the chosen package.



American Home Shield logo
Service Plus Home Warranty banner

Service Plus Home Warranty

  • Best for - Homeowners looking for affordable warranty
  • Average annual premium - $419 - $756
  • Service requests - 24/7 online and phone support

Service Plus Home Warranty offers outstanding home warranty protection for major appliances and systems. Service response time is fast through 24/7 support.

They have great discounts of up to $200 for upfront annual payments that come with flexible terms and competitive rates.

Service Plus Home Warranty provides a complete package of premium services designed to cover your home's appliances, electronics, and electrical equipment.



Service Plus Home Warranty logo
Complete Care Home Warranty banner

Complete Care Home Warranty

  • Best for - covering all major appliances
  • Average annual premium - $450 - $570
  • Service requests - 24/7 customer service and claims department with unlimited service calls

Complete Care Home Warranty offers replacement coverage for major appliances through three plan types: Systems, Combo, and Appliances.

The Complete Care Home Warranty has a 24/7 customer service and claims department, so homeowners get help anytime online or over the phone during business hours.

Homeowners can purchase a warranty for one or multiple years and assist with home repair, maintenance, and remodeling.

The warranty covers several home components, including heating, cooling, plumbing, electrical systems, appliances, and more.



Complete Care Home Warranty logo
Home Service Club banner
  • Best for - broad coverage options
  • Average annual premium - $552 - $799
  • Service requests - hotline service 24/7

The Home Service Club provides comprehensive warranties and service packages, including 100% coverage for home appliances and electronics and annual maintenance checks and emergency repairs.

Since its inception in 2018, the company has established national coverage. Membership includes access to a 24-hour service hotline and the members-only website to access the complete service portal.

Home Service Club offers two plans; a standard and comprehensive coverage. The standard plan covers 18 basic appliances, whereas the comprehensive covers 33 systems and appliances. Standard cover starts at $650 per year, while comprehensive starts at $799 per year. Service requests are available between 12 and 48 hours.



Home Service Club logo
AFC Home Club banner
  • Best for - extended guarantees
  • Average annual premium - $345 - $575
  • Service requests - support available online and via phone 24/7

The AFC Home Club is a new concept in-home warranty provider. It offers homeowners a comprehensive home warranty service that includes inspections, repairs, and replacement of defective appliances.

With AFC Home Club, you can protect your home against unexpected mechanical failures and electrical problems caused by faulty appliances. The service includes the cost of repairing or replacing defective appliances and furniture damaged by negligence, accidental or malicious damage, or normal wear and tear.

The AFC Home Club offers a reliable, economical, and personalized approach to home warranty services.

AFC Home Club provides affordable coverage for your appliances through its four plans: Systems, Silver, Gold, and Platinum. With 24/7 claims service, the BBB accredited company guarantees repairs for the life of your plan.



AFC Home Club logo
First Premier home Warranty banner

First Premier home Warranty

  • Best for - affordable fees
  • Average annual premium - $420 - $540
  • Service requests - chat, email, and phone support 24/7

The First Premier home warranty comes at reasonably low prices. You get two free months inclusive of its cover that includes a wide range of appliances. The first premier provides an option of add-ons if interested in more coverage.

It provides comprehensive coverage for homeowners of all ages, income levels, and home types and is known for its exceptional customer service.

Their home warranty services cover many issues, including home repairs, replacement of damaged household items, and home upgrades



First Premier home Warranty logo
Advanced Home Warranty banner

Advanced Home Warranty

  • Best for - Comprehensive coverage
  • Average annual premium - $476 - $660
  • Service requests - 24/7 hotline

Advanced Home Warranty provides two plans; the basic plan starting at $46.66 per month and the total plan covering all major appliances, including dryers, air conditioners, and refrigerators, starting at $55 per month.

Advanced Home Warranty protects specific mechanical and electrical components of covered home systems. It also offers protection for home appliances, including air conditioners, ranges, dishwashers, water heaters, dryers, garbage disposals, and fireplaces.



Advanced Home Warranty logo
First American Home Warranty banner

First American Home Warranty

  • Best for - multiple claims
  • Average annual premium - $372 - $546
  • Service requests - unlimited requests with 24/7 online and phone claims support

For more than 35 years, First American Home Warranty has been offering free and unlimited inspection of your home's electrical system and plumbing as well as annual inspections of heating and cooling systems, home warranties, and appliances. It also offers full-service coverage from licensed technicians for the repair of home systems as well as special inspections for items such as plumbing, heating, and cooling systems.

First American Home warranty combines customizable coverage with its fast, hassle-free claims process. You choose how much coverage you need by selecting four levels (Basic, Plus, Elite, and Premier) for your appliances, electronics, HVAC equipment, and plumbing system.



First American Home Warranty logo
Top 11 Home Warranty Providers


Our Research Has Helped Millions of Users To Get Lowest Prices From Leading Providers.

Our rating system


Compare the best brands side by side


Work only with suppliers you choose


Compare quotes to save money